Are Hunches the sign of a good marketer, or is it analytics?

This is an interesting perspective shared by Jack Holt…as he says most of the great marketing idea’s eventually are recognized by  someone having a gut reaction to the ideation that has taken place and going with that gut feeling in committing to the campaign, but The Page Group doesn’t want you to forget that Gut Reactions in marketing come from knowing your customer, knowing your products, knowing your brand story and taking that knowledge to develop the skills that tell our gut this is a good way to go.   In everyday life we learn to follow our instincts but they rarely succeed if we don’t have the back knowledge to let us understand what our gut is telling us to do.



Should You Trust The Numbers Or Go With Your Gut?

CMO EXCLUSIVES | January 28, 2014

by Jack Holt
Co-Founded & CEO


Have you ever had a feeling you just couldn’t shake? Of course you have—“hunches” are the hallmark of any good marketer. It means you know a good campaign when you see it.


  • Breakthrough ideas don’t come from an analytics dashboard—they come from intuitive leaps.
  • Thanks to the viral nature of modern media, one wrong hunch can devastate a brand.
  • Trust yourself, trust your gut, and then use data to support your hunches.

In fact, marketing decisions have historically been built on hunches, intuition, and other unquantifiable ideas. That’s easy to forget in this data-driven industry we now work in.

Here’s something else many people are forgetting: Breakthrough ideas don’t come from an analytics dashboard. They come from intuitive leaps.

So how do you know when you have a good idea in front of you? Popular wisdom says you should “trust your gut.” At Gigaom’s Roadmap 2013, Instagram co-founder Kevin Systrom also talked at length about hunch-driven design development. He maintained that it was Instagram’s secret to success.

Instagram began as an app called “Burbn.” Systrom had had a hunch. He polled its 100 users and found they were sharing photos more than anything else. Less than two years later, Instagram had more than 100 million users and a $1 billion price tag.

In Systrom’s world, data-based design plays an essential role in this process, but it’s about optimizing products, not developing them. Why? Systrom knows that the only way to develop something unique is with intuition, which is where your experience and instinct pay off.

Think about Systrom’s example in terms of a product campaign: Focus groups can guide you and offer you a tentative response. Despite the graphs and surveys, however, you still know that the final decision has to come from you, not the data. You have to trust your experience, your team, and, most of all, yourself.

Remember The Risks
Lots of marketing executives tell themselves that the decision they’re making isn’t risky because it’s based on data. But they’re wrong.

Some businesses live (and die) by the mantra, “Data doesn’t lie.” This is fine for objective measurements, such as impressions, click-throughs, and transactions, but for qualitative, subjective data—such as target interests, psychographics, and social data—it’s not nearly as clear-cut. Every single day, people lie, misremember, or skew the truth on surveys, in focus groups, and through comments and reviews.

Other flaws are at work: Whether they mean to or not, analysts bring biases when they organize data for a report. And data can certainly still be wrong, even when it’s laid out perfectly in an Excel chart or a PowerPoint deck. In the end, the wrong kind of data-driven approach isn’t that different from traditional market research: It’s lengthy, costly, and still means making some really big, dangerous assumptions.

There’s another angle of risk here: Thanks to the viral nature of modern media, one wrong hunch can devastate a brand. Now when a marketer makes the wrong call, millions of people can see it.

Scared? You should be.

But the good news is, when you get it right, viral recognition happens then, too. Netflix had a hunch that political cynicism would resonate with its audience, and it knew that “binge watching” was a trend among users. So Netflix released the entire first season of “House of Cards” at once. The move was so successful that Netflix is repeating that model with several other series.

Strengthen Your Strategy
The evidence in support of hunches is there. Marketers can get it right. But data can’t be discounted either. That’s why the best path forward is an integrated one, and there’s a specific strategy for marketers that combines data- and hunch-based approaches.

Think of your precampaign period as hunch-based. That means you trust your instinct on what your target wants, needs, and will respond to. Then, after you’ve crafted a campaign guided by instinct and intuition, you can use hard data to back up your strategy and optimize it.

There are lots of unique ways to hone your data for a more helpful, relevant viewpoint, such as using carefully selected focus groups or accessing social media platforms to get a closer look at your fans and followers. This will give you an in-depth, holistic look at who your target is, what they care about, and how they’re growing and changing so you can speak to them as people, not just customers.

Marketing isn’t just about crunching numbers—it relies on experience, knowing your audience, and having great intuition. Trust yourself, trust your gut, and then use data to support your hunches.


To learn more about big data, attend the Adobe Summit, March 24-28. Click here to view the agenda.

About Jack Holt

Jack Holt is co-founder and CEO of Mattr, which offers software that segments brands’ social audience with personality analysis.

Written by

9 Comments to “Are Hunches the sign of a good marketer, or is it analytics?”

  1. Anonymous says:

    Thanks for giving this kind of great subject material on your web site. I came across it on the search engines. I will check to come back whenever you publish more aricles.

  2. Anonymous says:

    I’d have to grant with you on this. Which is not something I usually do! I really like reading a post that will make people think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment!

  3. Anonymous says:

    This is a smart blog. I mean it. You have so much knowledge about this issue, and so much passion. You also know how to make people rally behind it, obviously from the responses. Youve got a design here thats not too flashy, but makes a statement as big as what youre saying. Great job, indeed.

  4. Anonymous says:

    I was very pleased to find this site. This is an intelligent and well written article, you must have put a fair amount of research into writing this. Thank you

  5. Anonymous says:

    Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and Im impressed! Extremely useful info specifically the last part 🙂 I care for such information much. I was seeking this particular info for a long time. Thank you and best of luck.

  6. Anonymous says:

    Aw, this was a really nice post. In idea I wish to put in writing like this moreover – taking time and precise effort to make an excellent article but what can I say I procrastinate alot and by no means seem to get one thing done.

  7. Anonymous says:

    This is a very carefully managed blog. It makes me want to sign up for the RSS feed 🙂

  8. Anonymous says:

    Wonderful write-up, Ive bookmarked this site so hopefully Ill discover more on this topic in the future!

  9. Google says:

    We prefer to honor quite a few other world wide web internet sites on the web, even though they arent linked to us, by linking to them.

Leave a Reply